Ranking The Top 15 Marshall Basketball Players Of All Time

Over the years, elite talent has made its way through Huntington on the basketball court. With basketball season now officially in full swing, a question arose in my mind – who is considered the best of the best from Marshall University? After thorough studying, consideration, and research, the following names represent what I believe to be the 15 greatest Marshall basketball players to ever grace the court.

Before we delve into the list, it's important to note that creating it was no easy task. Initially, I planned to compile a list of only the top ten Marshall players. However, out of respect, I expanded it to 15, as omitting certain names felt disrespectful. Please understand that this list reflects my opinion and research, as many of these players were before my time, and I did not personally witness their performances. This is all in good fun, and if you disagree with my list, I welcome constructive dialogue.

Honorable Mentions

Ajdin Penava (2015–2018)

The 6'9" big man from Bosnia began his Marshall career coming off the bench in his freshman and sophomore seasons. Penava truly shone in his junior year, contributing significantly to Marshall's memorable 2017-2018 season. Averaging 15.6 PPG and 8.5 RPG, Penava displayed a unique combination of size and athleticism. His notable performance against regional rival Ohio University, with 33 points, 15 rebounds, and 9 blocks, showcased his versatility. Penava earned several accolades, including being named to the 3rd Team All C-USA, 1st Team All C-USA Defensive Team, C-USA Defensive Player of the Year, and leading the NCAA in blocks. His contributions were crucial to Marshall's success in both the C-USA Championship and a historic NCAA Tournament win over Wichita State. Penava chose to pursue a professional career, signing a 4-year deal with Kirolbet Baskonia of the Liga ACB EuroLeague in 2018. As of 2023, he continues to play professionally, having signed a one-year deal with Juventus Utena of the Lithuanian Basketball League.

Ryan Taylor (2012–2017)

Taylor, known for his vibrant personality, arrived on campus in 2012 and redshirted his first year. By 2013, he secured a spot in the starting rotation and demonstrated a physical style of play that defied his 6'5" stature. Reminiscent of Charles Barkley, Taylor distinguished himself with occasional 3-point shots. He played a pivotal role in transforming the culture of Marshall basketball, contributing to some of the program's best years. Taylor's success included being named to the C-USA Freshman Team in 2014, 3rd Team All C-USA in 2015 and 2017, and C-USA All-Defensive Team in 2017. He became Marshall's first player to achieve career totals of 1,500 points, 800 rebounds, and 250 assists. Currently, Taylor ranks as the 10th all-time leading scorer in Marshall history with 1,778 points and the 3rd all-time rebounder with 985 boards. After playing overseas in Iceland and contributing to a CBA championship with the Indianapolis Blaze in 2019, Taylor returned to Marshall as the Assistant Director of Operations for the coaching staff. He is truly a Marshall great who will be remembered in the program's history.

15. Jason Williams (1994-1996)

Let the controversy begin! I understand many people might be thinking, "Jason Williams at 15? You must be kidding!" But please allow me to explain. Jason Williams is a West Virginia basketball legend. His senior year at Dupont High School is etched into the memories of WV natives. Alongside another future Marshall superstar, Randy Moss, Williams and Co won the state championship in 1994. That same year, Williams was named the WV player of the year, also being the only Dupont High School basketball player to score over 1,000 points and 500 assists in a career. Despite planning to attend Providence College, a coaching change led him to choose Marshall. Williams redshirted his freshman year, and in the 1995-1996 season, he began his college career, averaging 13.4 PPG and 6.4 APG. When Billy Donovan took the head coaching position at Florida University, Williams followed him, enjoying a successful collegiate career. Selected 7th overall in the NBA draft, Williams had a lengthy and successful run as a professional player. While he's remembered as one of the most talented players from WV, his position on this list considers his impact specifically during his one season at Marshall.

14. Leo Byrd (1955-1959)

Byrd, a native of Huntington, WV, began his basketball career at Huntington High School, averaging a state record of 34.2 points per game in his senior year (1954-1955). Enrolling at Marshall College in 1955, Byrd couldn't play immediately due to NCAA rules against freshmen playing varsity. His sophomore year with the Herd saw him playing in all 24 games, averaging 16.4 PPG. His scoring increased to 24.9 PPG in his junior year and led the MAC in scoring with 704 points in his senior year. Byrd earned First Team All-MAC in 1958 and 1959 and Second Team Consensus All American in 1959. Picked 25th overall in the 1959 NBA draft by the Cincinnati Royals, he never played professionally but joined the 1959 Pan American Games, winning a gold medal. Byrd passed away in 1991 at the age of 54, and Marshall retired his number 44.

13. Charlie Slack (1952-1956)

Charlie Slack is considered one of the greatest rebounders in college basketball history. Accumulating 1,916 boards during his time at Marshall, a record that still stands today and is considered the 3rd best in college basketball history. His most impressive performance was against the University of Charleston, where he brought in 43 rebounds in a single game (the second-highest single-game rebound total in NCAA history). Slack, selected by the Fort Wayne Pistons in the 1956 NBA Draft, never played professionally but joined the 1960 USA Olympic team, winning a gold medal. Slack passed away on July 3rd, 2020, at the age of 89, and Marshall retired the number 17 in his honor.

12. DeAndre Kane (2010-2012)

Herd fans will remember DeAndre Kane as a terrific all-around player. In his freshman year, he averaged 15.1 PPG and 3.4 APG, earning a spot on the C-USA all-freshman team. Kane remained consistent over the next two seasons, being named 2nd team all C-USA in both his sophomore and junior years. In 2012, Kane led the Herd to the C-USA championship game, falling just short against Memphis. After graduating, Kane transferred to Iowa State for his final year of eligibility, earning recognition as a 3rd Team All-American and being in the top 30 of the Naismith College Player of The Year award. Undrafted, he joined the Lakers for summer league appearances before playing professionally in various countries, currently in Iceland. Fans may also remember Kane as part of the 2021 Boeheim’s Army that won the TBT tournament. Considering the level of competition he faced, there's no doubt he is one of the all-time greats at Marshall.

11. Mike D’Antoni (1970-1973)

Mike D’Antoni conducted one of the greatest Marshall basketball teams ever. Upon arriving at Marshall, he faced an interesting situation with his brother, Coach Danny D’Antoni, who had just graduated and returned to coach the freshman team in 1970. So, history had a D’Antoni on the sideline and one on the court making plays. As part of the varsity squad in his sophomore season, Mike assumed the role of the team's leader, orchestrating the offense as a point guard. While not the fastest or the biggest, D’Antoni's basketball IQ set him apart. He remains 3rd all-time at Marshall for assists with 659 in his career. His final year at Marshall was remarkable, achieving a 23-4 record, finishing 8th in the AP Poll and 12th in the final poll – the highest rankings in Marshall's history. After Marshall, D’Antoni was selected in the NBA draft by the Kansas City Kings and the ABA draft by the San Antonio Spurs. Playing four seasons in the NBA and ABA, he then continued his career in Italy, becoming one of the country's best players. Winning numerous championships and accolades, including being in the top 50 of the greatest contributors in EuroLeague history, D’Antoni's number 8 is retired with Olimpia Milano. Transitioning to coaching, he is a 2x NBA Coach of the Year, 2x NBA All-Star Team Coach, 2x Gold Medal winner as the head coach of the USA international team, and a recognized figure for changing the game of basketball with his fast-paced uptempo style. Mike D’Antoni is Marshall basketball royalty, and his (and his brother's) number 10 is retired at Marshall.

10. James Kelly (2015-2016)

Though James Kelly didn't spend much time at Marshall, he undeniably left his mark on the Herd. Starting his college career at Owens Community College, he gained attention with excellent performances during his freshman and sophomore seasons. Transferring to the University of Miami for his junior year, things didn't work out, leading him to finish his college career at Marshall after sitting out a season due to transfer rules. Once eligible, Kelly took C-USA by storm. Standing at 6’8 and 240 pounds, he played like a force of nature, reminiscent of LeBron James. During his senior season at Marshall, Kelly averaged 20 PPG, 1.3 SPG, 1.1 BPG, becoming one of only two players to gather 600 points and 300 rebounds in a single season. He was named the C-USA Newcomer of the year and 1st team all C-USA. Despite Marshall not achieving their desired season, Kelly is remembered as a bridge player who ushered in a new generation of success. After his time at Marshall, Kelly spent some time in the Charlotte Hornets organization for their summer league, then was selected 8th overall in the Korean Basketball League. Continuing to play professionally, he joined the Marshall alum TBT team, Herd That, bringing back wonderful memories for fans.

9. Tamar Slay (1998-2002)

A product of Woodrow Wilson High School in Beckley, Tamar Slay was one of the greatest basketball players to emerge from West Virginia. Named to the all-state team three times and leading his team to two state titles, he continued his success upon arriving at Marshall. A four-year starter, Slay was among the most productive players in Herd History, particularly known for his 3-point shooting. He made 251 3-point shots during his time with the Herd, a record that still stands. Ranking 9th in all-time scoring in Marshall history, he was named 1st team All-MAC in 2000. In 2002, Slay was drafted in the second round by the New Jersey Nets and played for them before moving to the Charlotte Bobcats in 2004. He then embarked on a successful professional career overseas. In 2022, Slay joined the coaching staff at Marshall as an assistant coach, leaving the position in May 2022 for personal reasons.

8. JR Vanhoose (1998-2002)

Few players could match JR Vanhoose's scoring and rebounding prowess. Hailing from Paintsville, Kentucky, it was evident that Vanhoose had serious basketball skills. A two-time "Mr. Basketball" in Kentucky, he earned All-American honors, accumulating over 3,000 points and 2,000 rebounds. Upon arriving in Huntington, he made an impact from day one, earning a spot on the 1999 MAC freshman team. By his senior year, Vanhoose achieved 1st team All-MAC and Academic All-American honors. Today, he stands at number 8 overall in points for the Herd with 1,803, ranking as the school's 2nd-best rebounder with 1,086 in his career. Currently a high school teacher and coach in Kentucky, Vanhoose frequently visits Huntington for various Marshall sporting events, earning immense love from Herd fans.

7. Skip Henderson (1984-1988)

Henderson played a pivotal role for the Herd during the SoCon days, leaving an indelible mark. The point guard contributed to two SoCon regular season and tournament championships in 1985 and 1987. Leading the team in points for all four seasons and steals for his last three, Henderson's impact was profound. His legendary 55-point game against the Citadel remains a Marshall record. Henderson received 1st team all SoCon honors four times, was part of the SoCon freshman team in 1985, won the SoCon Player of the Year in 1988, and received AP honorable mention All-American recognition. Unfortunately, post his Marshall career, Henderson faced off-court issues, leading to a life sentence. His story serves as a reminder that talent cannot compensate for a serious lack of character. Despite the challenges, I appreciate his contributions to Marshall University as a player, and I hope he finds peace in his life.

6. Russell Lee (1969-1972)

Russell Lee was a phenom at Marshall, showcasing his skills over four seasons. Averaging 23.9 points per game and 11.3 rebounds per game, Lee concluded his Marshall career 7th in all-time scoring with 1,815 points and 6th all-time in rebounding with 863 boards. Graduating from Marshall, he was selected 6th overall in the 1972 NBA draft by the Milwaukee Bucks. Lee's number 55 is now retired at Marshall, cementing his legacy with the Herd.

5. John Taft (1987-1991)

John Taft, a highly sought-after recruit from Huntsville, Alabama, opted to join the Herd instead of Alabama University or LSU. This proved to be a fantastic career decision as Taft averaged 21.6 points throughout his career with the Herd, scoring over 2,000 points. In 1990, Marshall basketball faced probation, allowing players like Taft to transfer with immediate eligibility. Despite offers from other schools, Taft chose to stay with Marshall, going on to be named 1st Team all SoCon from 1989-1991 and the SoCon player of the year in 1990 and 1991. Taft's loyalty is remembered today as his number 22 is retired at Marshall after a successful professional career in Iceland.

4. Hasan Whiteside (2009-2010)

When Whiteside chose to play at Marshall, it was an "under the radar" move, but he quickly made his mark in college basketball. Whiteside's incredible performance over rival Ohio University earned him recognition in ESPN Magazine. Throughout the season, he collected three triple-doubles, led the nation in blocked shots with 182, and broke the C-USA record for blocked shots in a single season. Whiteside's achievements include being named a 2nd team All American, All C-USA Defensive Team, C-USA Freshman of The Year, and more. After Marshall's coach left, Whiteside declared for the NBA draft, becoming the 33rd overall pick in 2010. His professional career had its ups and downs, but he eventually became one of the best centers in the NBA. Out of all the players who have attended Marshall, Whiteside is perhaps the most dominant player we have ever seen.

3. Taevion Kinsey (2018-2023)

Taevion Kinsey, arriving from Eastmoor Academy in Columbus, Ohio, made an instant impact at Marshall. His memorable performances, including a 23-point, 7-rebound game against rival WKU, showcased his talent. Kinsey led Marshall to a CBI Tournament Title with an impressive 21-point, 11-rebound performance. Over his college career, he became the face of Marshall basketball and a leader in the locker room. Kinsey's decision to return for the 2022-2023 season contributed to a special year for Marshall, though they fell short in the SBC Tournament. Kinsey's accolades include multiple C-USA and SBC team selections, and he holds records in blocks, assists, rebounds, and is Marshall's all-time scoring leader. Kinsey, now with the Utah Jazz's G-League team, exemplifies the impact of staying loyal to a program.

2. Jon Elmore (2015-2019)

Jon Elmore is undeniably the most crucial player in Herd basketball history. If I were to compare him to another Marshall athlete, he is the Chad Pennington of Marshall basketball. Elmore, born and raised in Charleston, WV, initially committed to play at VMI but later chose to enroll at Marshall. Joining the intramural team, Elmore caught the attention of Coach Danny D’Antoni, leading to his inclusion in the basketball team in December 2015. Over the years, Elmore dazzled Herd fans with his unbelievable play. Despite not being the most athletic or well-rounded player, his basketball IQ set him apart. Elmore became the heart and soul of Marshall basketball, setting the standard for fans' expectations. He led the team to unprecedented heights, being a three-time First Team All C-USA selection and the C-USA Tournament MVP. Elmore made C-USA history as the all-time assists leader and the conference's highest three-point shooter. In 2018, he led the Herd to the C-USA tournament championship, securing their first NCAA Tournament appearance in 31 years. Elmore's impact is etched in Marshall's record books, ranking 2nd in all-time scoring, 1st in assists, and 5th in steals. His contributions make him a defining figure in Marshall basketball history.

1. Hal Greer (1955-1958)

The statue outside the Cam Henderson Center honoring Hal Greer is a testament to his groundbreaking contributions and the example he set for Marshall basketball players. Born and raised in Huntington, WV, Greer, after a successful career at Douglas High School, became the first African American to play for a public college in West Virginia upon enrolling at Marshall. Over his career, Greer amassed 1,377 points, setting a record at the time, with an impressive .545 shooting percentage. Leading Marshall to a MAC championship in 1956, he secured the university's first NCAA Tournament appearance. In 1957 and 1958, Greer earned spots on the all MAC team and was named an All-American in 1958. Averaging 19.4 ppg and 10.8 rpg, he left an indelible mark on Marshall basketball. Selected 13th overall in the 1958 NBA draft, Greer went on to become a 10-time NBA All-Star, MVP of the 1968 All-Star Game, 2nd team all-NBA seven times, and an NBA champion in 1968. His legacy as the greatest basketball player in Marshall history lives on, with his number 15 retired by the Philadelphia 76ers and number 16 retired at Marshall. Hal Greer passed away in April 2018, but his impact continues to resonate in Huntington as the best to ever play for Marshall.

And that is the list! If you have made this far, thank you for joining me on this journey. I know this list is sure to start some controversy as there have been so many excellent players make their way through Marshall. Let the debates begin! Let me know where I was wrong. Who wasn’t on this list who deserved to be? Who do you think is the greatest Basketball player in Marshall history? Comment below or on social media. And as always, Go Herd!